Gary Jackson: Fire When Ready Pottery
A Chicago potter’s somewhat slanted view of clay & play
Categories: art fair, artists

So just let me just vent for a second…
while many art fairs work long & hard to invite quality artists to their events.
There are jury processes in place to choose who will participate each year.
The understanding is that everything displayed at the art fair was to have been
made by the artist. And for the most part I believe that to be true.

However… I do believe that there are some people who are riding on the fringe
of that rule. Some that are selling wholesale items under the guise of their own.
Photographers who buy stock photography instead of shooting their own.
Artists who do “some” of the work, but not all. Artists who are selling artwork
that just doesn’t “seem” right?!

Like the artist that was next to me this weekend… no, not Molly. The other side.
She was an Asian artist with embroidered “paintings” with thousands of perfect stitches.
Photo realism done with embroidery threads. So impressive, and somewhat
unbelievable,
that she not only won “Best of Fiber” – but also “Best of Show.”

Now don’t get me wrong, the artwork was incredibly beautiful. But a little “too”
beautiful for the price. What I believe to be “too elaborate” and “too detailed”
for the quantity of pieces and the price points. Now keep in mind, I’m not sure.
But you know when you have “a feeling” that it’s too good to be true?… that there’s
no way she can be making all of this?… the fact that the work is too precise to be
handmade – although it’s all claimed to be? Prices a little off the mark… silk wine bags
with supposedly hand-embroidered patches sewn on to them… being sold at
five for $20. That’s only $4 each!!! Not possible. Not even to mention the perfectly
sized & sealed plastic bag that each wine bag came in?! Curious…

And then the rumors begin… other artists who claim to see this same “booth of artwork”
at other fairs with a different “artist.” That the work is being imported from China.
The the images are being created by computer. That any image can be scanned in
and the embroidery kicked-out by the computer. That the “artist” is just a sales rep.

So here’s my word of warning… be careful when shopping at art fairs.
Please be sure that the artist is indeed the artist. Don’t just assume it’s all on the up & up.
If you think it’s too good to be true, it probably is. Ask questions. Double-check. Listen.
Make sure that the artist can explain their process. Hear their story. Feel their passion.

Support individual artists for their talents.
And not some mass-merchant who is infiltrating the art fair scene!

6 Comments

Kelly

October 1st, 2009

Your frustration is legit!
I’m sorry this is happening.

Makes me wonder about the people in charge that they would not be more diligent…. (and then to dole out awards for it!!!)
Boo!! Hiss! Bah!

C. Yalater

October 4th, 2009

It’s unusual for you to have negative comments on your blog about past fairs, usually you are quite pleased. You seldom make negative remarks about anything, so this must have really hit a sore spot, and I don’t blame you for being upset. Why didn’t the judges at the show inspect the work and then ask the seller to leave if they didn’t feel that the work was legitimate? I think they have that option, to ask someone to leave, if the items being sold are not as represented in the jurying process. I have been to a couple of shows where I have seen people take a photograph out of a box, put it into a manufactured frame (from a box labeled “Made in China”) and then pass it off as “handmade, one of a kind photography. I have also seen someone selling statues and such that were hand carved, but NOT by the person selling them, unless they spent the last ten years carving for twenty hours a day. Maybe when the economy improves, the fairs won’t be so quick to give a pass to anyone that can pay the booth/jurying fees, just so they can make a buck. I would be more than willing to help email the Art in the Barn folks, and ask them to be more CAREFUL in their artisan selection, and perhaps that person will not be back next year. AITB is a great show, and it would be sad to see it go the way of so many others that have succumbed to reselling, Costco memberships, and Pampered Chef vendors.

October 4th, 2009

Thanks for your support & encouragement… and you are correct, it did really bother me and the rest of the legitimate artists! The place was all “a-buzz” Sunday as the artists were all discussing the situation. Especially those who have seen the same “artwork” at different art fairs with a different artist each time. I too agree that it might be economy-influenced, but I doubt it. I hope that art fair organizers start to watch for this sort of “wholesale-reselling” activity as it diminishes the reputation of the art fair. If you would like to contact the organizers of Art In The Barn, they should know who she is… they gave her the award for “Best Of Show”!!!

Nancy

October 5th, 2009

I bought some – I loved it – it was really great. Maybe a big oops? I’m not going to worry about it and just enjoy it. But is there any comment for the organizers? I’d be interested….

October 5th, 2009

NANCY – I would agree. The pieces themselves are quite beautiful. And you should enjoy it. I’m not sure if the organizers are aware or not?! I would like to think they are… I know several people said they were going to report it.

October 15th, 2009

Hi Gary-

I just discovered that I’m on your favorite artists list – and I’m extremely flattered! (By the way, I tried to post a similar comment earlier today, but it’s not showing here. Probably shouldn’t try to do this from work computers)

Regarding these “artists”, I know which one you’re talking about, and she’s not the only one. I’ve seen other booths at several shows with the same art but different so-called artists. They’re not just from Asia, either. I don’t want to be the one who tattles on the impostors to the committees, but really, they should be able to tell the difference between a dedicated artist and a phony. A show like Art in the Barn, where they rely on a percentage of sales, probably appreciates a big seller like that one and doesn’t want to ask questions.

Leave a Comment